LUMBERTON — A Lumberton man who had been missing for a week was found shot dead in a Fifth Street auto shop on Monday after the shop owner admitted to killing the man during an argument over rent money, according to Lumberton police.
Hilton Oxendine Jr., 62, of Lumberton, was charged with first-degree murder in the shooting death of Clarence Stephen Maynor, 63, according to Lumberton police Capt. Johnny Barnes. Oxendine was placed in the Robeson County jail without bond.
Oxendine told police that Maynor came to his shop, West Fifth Street Tire & Auto, on Feb. 20.
“They got into an argument over money and the lease, the argument turned to a shoving match, and Oxendine grabbed a handgun that he had there and shot him,” Barnes said. “… After he shot him, he left the body laying there right where he fell.”
Maynor was shot “more than once” in the “mid-section,” according to Barnes.
According to Barnes, Oxendine went to the Sheriff’s Office on Monday and told Maj. Howard Branch that Stephen Maynor’s body was inside the Fifth Street garage.
Maynor’s black 2007 Chevrolet Corvette was found parked inside the garage, Barnes said. A handgun was recovered at the scene, he said.
Maynor, who lived at Ocean Isle Beach but also maintained a home on Sherwood Road in Lumberton, was reported missing on Thursday by a co-worker. The co-worker had last spoken to Maynor on Feb. 20, doing so by telephone, according to Branch.








A person who accuses another of not being factual should at least have a few correct facts of their own. The account given by "lookingforanswers" is correct and factual. You ask how I know. These facts were presented to me by the Lead Detective on this case. The presentation included the autopsy report and photos. The autopsy report is "public record" and available to everyone. The discussion with the Police Dept. is only for family members.
YES, Steve has a brother so get your facts right OR STOPIT.
I to have been presented information from this case, there seems to be a problem some where, because we are getting our information from the same place, but it does not seem to match. So, something is wrong some where.
I do know that many members of the Maynor family are friends with members in the Oxendine family and that alot of these comments are NOT helping either family. What WE All should be doing is praying for the families involved. I do know that members of the Maynor family have been to visit the Oxendine family as well as called them, both families have been friends for years.
I NEVER said that Steve didn't have a brother. I stated that if Steve was such a GREAT person, why did the ONLY brother he had, choose NOT to have a relationship with him for the PAST EIGHT years. Steve's brother DID admit to that at his services, didn't he?
God, Steve, and Hilton only know the truth but there is more to this murder than meets the eye.
For example, do any of you know that steve was shot twice in the stomach and once in the back of his head behind his right ear.
How can such actions be justified shooting a man three times, leaving him for dead, hiding his car, closing up shop for a week and confessing seven days later. After looking at the factors, justification does not come to mind but premeditated does. Keep in mind, in a court of law everyone is presumed innocent until proven guilty. Why is a man who committed such a crime allowed a bond of $25,000 only and out of jail in on day. And shortly after this incident, in a recent dog fighting bust, the dog fighter's bond was ($35,000). How is this even possible. A human life versus a dog, there is not comparison. A family did not have a chance to look upon steve's face one last time, a family still looking for answers to such as crime that seems insignificant since the person that pulled trigger acts as if its nothing and the judicial system apparently thought the same. Or could it be that old faithful good old boy system of Robco.Interesting, no. Did you know that Steve and Hilton were friends, that they were golfing buddies, and that Steve helped drum up car business by referring people in the community to purchase cars from Hilton.
No one is perfect, we all fall short and we all get angry. Ephesians 4:26 states Be ye angry and sin not, let not the sun go down upon your wrath (Ephesians 4:26).
Looking for answers
Steve had one brother that had not spoken to him in eight years, if he was such a good person, why would his only brother have choosen not to have a relationship with him if he was such a good person?
Steve never drummed up nothing for Hilton!
Henberry45,
We have written ONE story about this alleged murder. I can't control the fact that people want to comment on it.
Donnie Douglas
Editor
The Robesonian
to court? And even then good luck finding a jury who isn't
friends with him and will let him off. there are two losses in this case for two families and a community. And too bad for the son who I hear should be used to fixing peoples problems with that drunk of a girlfriend of his. I pray for peace for both families, but as a previous poster said, we should expect the justice system to work in this case.
My heart is saddened by this, he was a great man who deserves some friends at his service even thou he only had a distant brother.
Judgenot,
I overlooked it. Went back and found and approved. Sorry.
Donnie Douglas
Editor
The Robesonian
You never really know anyone and often times you never will truly know someone unless the layers are pulled back publicly. History is full of good and even great people until they're exposed for what they really are; murderers, pedophiles, rapist, drug dealers, thevies, spies, etc... and the list goes on and on. They're all often thought of as good people until proven otherwise.
Case in point, John Wayne Gacy. He was father, husband, businessman and community volunteer among other things. He was even once given U.S. Secret Service clearance and spent time with President Carter's wife, First Lady Rosalyn Carter, doing charity work. It wasn't until years later that he, like Hilton, "turned himself in and confessed" to the authorities what he had done. Cops then went to Gacys house and excavated 26 bodies from the crawl space. It wasn't until that moment did everyone realize he wasn't as great a man as previously thought.
Maybe Hilton was a good person prior to the events of Feb 20th. I'm just looking at his confessed actions and the delay of a solid week...
I agree with you and scaryjerry!!